Marxian exploitation
Introduction
My understanding of Marx’s theory of exploitation is that it starts by observing that there is class resentment of the capitalists by the proletariat, it proceeds by judging that this is an undesirable state of affairs, continues by assuming that the resentment is justified by the exploitation of the proletariat by the capitalists, and concludes by locating the exploitation in the appropriation by the capitalists of the economic surplus produced by the labour of the proletariat.
The observation is true: there is such resentment; the judgement is subjective, or at least its moral valence can’t be assessed without additional analysis; the assumption is of no value without evidence; the location of exploitation in the appropriation of economic surplus is false, or at least need not be true, and that’s what I demonstrate in this article.
Workers producing artefacts
Consider a scenario in which a worker can work to produce a particular artefact. Producing the artefact requires working in 12 stages, one after the other, each stage taking 1 month.1 At the end of 12 months the worker can sell the artefact on the open market for $61,000. There is no exploitation here. Marx defines exploitation as the surplus value that is not paid to workers for their labour, and the worker keeps all the money paid in exchange for the result of his labour.
Now suppose a capitalist employs 12 workers who work on an assembly line, such that worker 1 always works on stage 1 of artefact production, worker 2 always works on stage 2, and so on up to worker 12 who always works on stage 12. One artefact is completed per month, which the capitalist can sell on the open market for $61,000. Suppose further he uses that revenue to pay each of the 12 workers a monthly wage of $5,000 and keeps $1,000 for himself. Here is the capitalist’s cash flow report:
| wages | $60,000 |
|---|---|
| profit | $1,000 |
| sales | $61,000 |
Marx locates the exploitation in the capitalist system here: the capitalist has arranged for the workers to produce artefacts (true), and he sells the product of the workers’ labour for its market value (true), retains some of the proceeds (true) and pays the workers less than the value that they created (false).
Exploitation?
How can it be false that the workers are paid less than the value that they created? After all, 12 workers received $5,000 each, i.e. $60,000 in total, for working together to produce one artefact, whereas one worker working alone receives $61,000 for producing the same artefact. How does the difference arise? The difference arises from when the workers are paid. When working alone, payment is only received at the end of a year; working for the capitalist, payment is received at the end of every month. If a worker were to invest his monthly wage at the prevailing interest rate he would end up with more than $60,000 from his labour at the end of 12 months. Assuming that the prevailing interest rate is 3.66% per year (equivalent to 0.3% per month, compounded),2 a worker who invests his entire monthly wage for 12 months will have $61,000 at the end of the year,3 exactly the same amount as the worker who worked alone!
Work in progress
So, workers who work for the capitalist are not receiving less than if they worked alone, but that in itself does not prove that the capitalist is not exploiting them. After all the capitalist takes $1,000 of the revenue for doing seemingly nothing. How can that be justified? One could attempt to say that the capitalist is being paid for “organising the workers”, “having the idea to set up the business” or “taking the risk that the product won’t sell”, each of which may be a valid justification in some scenarios, but none of which is needed to justify the profit in the scenario we are considering. In our scenario the justification is much easier: the capitalist is receiving interest on the work in progress.
What is “work in progress”? Consider what happens during each month: worker 12, working on stage 12 of the production line, receives from worker 11 a partial artefact that is 11/12ths complete and turns it into a complete artefact for the capitalist to sell; but also worker 11, working on stage 11, receives from worker 10 a 10/12ths complete artefact and turns it into a 11/12ths complete artefact for worker 12 to work on next month; worker 10 receives a 9/12th complete artefact and turns it into a 10/12ths complete artefact, all the way back to worker 1 who creates a 1/12th artefact from raw materials.
In summary, the work of each month starts from work in progress from the previous month. The work in progress at the start, and at the end, of any month is, in aggregate, the result of 664 person-months of work. Each month of work costs $5,000, so its total capitalized cost is close to $330,000.5 The capitalist’s income, $1,000 per month, is exactly the interest due on an investment of this size. In order to start up the production line the capitalist needed to produce or purchase 66 person-months of partial artefacts and his $1,000 monthly “profit” is simply the interest on that investment.
Time preference
An important facet of this scenario is that the capitalist is paid not because he has a “different time preference” to the workers, nor because he is “forwarding the workers wages”. Such phenomena may arise in certain scenarios, but in this scenario the capitalist receives payment for the sold artefact contemporaneously with the wages that he pays to the workers. The workers are not being paid before the value is generated. To the extent that “time preference” is relevant it is simply a global preference, through the prevailing interest rate, and applies to the work in progress, not to the cash flow. The workers are being paid for work which was based on someone else’s work in progress. That explains the capitalist’s income.
Böhm-Bawerk
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk refuted Marx’s exploitation theory in Capital and Interest in 1884. Supposedly Marx countered in the chapter Interest and Profit of Enterprise of Capital Vol. III by relocating exploitation to interest itself, interest being the profit of some earlier labour, but that line of argument seems question-begging to me. Böhm-Bawerk used an example of a steam-engine which takes five years to complete, which is rather similar to our first example in which a worker makes an artefact alone. I prefer the example of an assembly line with work in progress because it removes time preference from the equation (except to the extent that time preference explains interest).
The labour theory of value
The scenario presented in this article demonstrates that Marx’s conception of the labour theory of value is blind to some sources of value and, therefore, his conclusion from it of exploitation fallacious. His theory fails to incorporate that not just the amount of labour that goes into making a product contributes to its value, but also when that labour was performed. I suspect that Marx believed, the value of a good being the “socially necessary labour required for its reproduction”, that a good produced as the result of work in a sequence of 12 month-long stages has the same value as a good produced by 12 workers working in parallel for one month. Similarly, I expect that he would say that the value of a cask of fresh grape juice is the same as the value of the contents of the same cask after a year-long fermentation processes has turned it into wine. He simply fails to take into account that sequentiality is an unavoidable aspect of some production processes. Seequentiality is a property that is nicely accommodated in capitalism, the capitalist participating in the production process by contributing work in progress, and receiving interest in return.
References
Why Marx’s Exploitation Theory Is Wrong (Joseph Salerno explains Böhm-Bawerk)
Responding to an Austrian Economist on the Theory of Exploitation
For simplicity let’s assume that producing the artefact requires no specific tools, and the effort gathering the raw materials needed to produce the artefact is incorporated into this 12 months of labour, and that the materials otherwise have no cost – perhaps wood is gathered from a nearby ample forest.↩︎
\(1.003^{12} = 1.0366\)↩︎
\(5000 * (1.003^{12} - 1) / 0.003 = 61000\)↩︎
\((11 * 12) / 2 = 66\)↩︎
Due to compounding, the true value is closer to $333,333.↩︎